Greta by J.S. Lemon

Greta by J.S. Lemon
Publisher:  Farrar, Straus and Giroux Books for Younger Readers
Format:  Hardcover ARC
Number of pages:   208 pages
Publishing:   September 10th, 2024
Source:  Banholzer PR

Opening Line:  "When I sit on the vine that grows outside my best friend Lotti's window, I have a perfect view."


Greta Goodwin lives with her mom, dad and younger brother, Fej.  Her family is currently getting ready to move to a new neighborhood and Greta's mom is adamant that she finish packing up her bedroom.  Lotti, Greta's best friend, has come over to help, but the girls find themselves distracted by thoughts of beginning seventh grade, choosing outfits for the first day, navigating puberty, and contemplating their first boyfriends—subjects that Lotti and Greta feel unprepared to tackle.

The beginning of the school year brings many changes, including a few classmates who have noticeably matured over the summer, capturing the attention of both the girls and boys in class.  Due to a few snickers and snide comments, Greta decides to keep a low profile and not draw attention to herself.  However, after getting a new haircut, Derek comes up to her and offers a compliment on her new look.  He proceeds to ask whether she's coming to a party and says he'll see her there.  During the party, Derek approaches her again.  At first, she's flattered by his attention, but quickly it starts to feel uncomfortable due to his aggressive advances, and his refusal to accept her "no" as an answer.  Greta then tracks down Lotti and the two call her parents to come and pick them up early from the party.  Afterwards, Greta begins to feel like everyone is aware of the incident, that she's somehow different and changed, she's even unable to confide in anyone what transpired, including her best friend.   Greta is plagued by nightmares of hands reaching for her, followed by her body undergoing mysterious transformations.  

I'm going to make every attempt not to leave any spoilers in my review, but it will be challenging. Greta tackles the sensitive subject of sexual assault very delicately.  It conveys Greta's immediate responses and the subsequent challenges she faces upon returning to school and seeing Derek again.  Derek's behavior is depicted as reprehensible, yet it was troubling to me that he didn't face any consequences for his actions.  

The story features short chapters of roughly four to six pages.  The early descriptions of Lotti and Greta's friendship really conveys the deep connection or bond that the two girls share.  They are best friends who share everything with one another, from the excitement to the nervousness about the first day of middle school.  Even their fears, anxieties, and apprehensions about how things will change.  It's therefore surprising that Greta didn't feel comfortable in sharing what happened to her with Derek to Lotti, given how close they are.   And yet, people often respond to a trauma in different ways too.

My biggest challenge with the story is the conclusion, which left me with mixed feelings.  I appreciated how Greta's transformation symbolized her seeing herself as beautiful and how she felt empowered.  Greta reclaiming her body as something that shouldn't be objectified was also a very powerful statement.  I guess my difficulty lied in her eventual disappearance following her transformation, being concerned with how that messaging could be perceived.  I had wished that she could have conveyed the sexual assault to Lotti, her parents even a trusted adult.  

The speed at which Greta processed the trauma also felt too quick to me.  There's a myriad of emotions that I'd expected Greta to navigate her way through, including guilt, sadness, and anger.  Some were briefly touched on, like her blow up at school resulting in her suspension, it still appeared that her fantastical transformation overshadowed the ending.  The story is intended to be hopeful, but the resolution still involved her disappearing from the people in her life who were closest to her.  Although, she visited each of them briefly, and they seemed to recognize her presence in her current form, I still felt a sense of sadness in those last few pages.  Greta might have felt liberated and free, but I couldn't help feeling sad.

While I enjoyed the messaging the book was trying to convey and the magical realism mixed with fantasy, I think this might be confusing to some and will be best read by a more mature reader who can appreciate the symbolism of Greta's metamorphosis.  At the back of the book, Dr. Alycia Davis, a clinical psychologist provides valuable information on sexual assault, the accompany emotions and ways to get help. 

  **A huge thank you to Banholzer PR and Farrar, Straus and Giroux Books for Younger Readers for the hardcover copy in exchange for an honest review. **